Mapping People’s Feelings in a Neighborhood: technique, analysis and applications
Dr. Yodan Rofé - Unit of Desert Architecture and Urban Planning. Department of Man in the Desert. The Jacob Blaustein Institute for Desert Research. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel
SICI: 1723-0093(200408)4<T:MPFIAN>2.0.CO;2-Q
.
Abstract

This paper presents a new method of surveying people’s feelings in the environment, at the neighborhood scale. It attempts to bridge a gap between neighbohrood quality studies which tend to rely on aggregate assessments of well-being, and environmental preference studies, which tend to concentrate on physical variables only and to rely on a highly structured set of stimuli.

The method centers on surveying people’s immediate feelings of well-being as they walk around a neighborhood area. The subjects note down their feelings, as they go, and according to where they feel them change. The individual observations are then aggregated into a composite “feeling map” of the area studied.

Three examples of feeling surveys are presented, and one is analyzed in detail. The analysis examines the degree of agreement between people, the sources of variation in feelings, and the correlation between people’s sense of well-being and physical, social and functional aspects of the neighborhood. The results show that there is a pattern of agreement between people, professionals and laymen alike, on their feelings in different areas of the neighborhood, and that the variation in feelings is correlated better with location in the neighborhood, than with the socio-economic characteristics of the observers.

...
Figure 1: Berkeley’s Southside aggregated feeling map

Figure 2: San Francisco Trans-bay Terminal area feeling map

Figure 3: The Golden Gate Neighborhood aggregated feeling map (south part only)
The paper concludes with a discussion of the possible use of this method in neighborhood planning and urban design. The potential of the method as a tool in citizen participation in planning, and as a vehicle for bridging between lay persons’ and professionals’ perspectives on the neighborhood, is highlighted.


 


Figure 8: Comparison between two buildings on Marshall Street

 

 


Figure 9: Two views of the Golden Gate Library on San Pablo Ave

 

 



 

 


Figure 10: Four views from the corner of 56th and Gaskill Streets

 
 
  Download the full paper (with no images): "Mapping People’s Feelings in a Neighborhood: technique, analysis and applications" (.pdf - 194 Kb)